Separate Comedy Section?

[lljwagg]

In the light of all the comedy albums that have been posted - would it be a good idea to have completely separate section just for comedy uploads (as it isn't music)?
Just an idea.
:D

[Baz]

Um...no this idea has been posted before and got rejected because for people like you who mass post with 2 post's it makes it harder on them to post action and comedy videos because they would have to be switching sections as they post.And it also makes it easyer on people to find what they need if there not sure what cat to look in.

[pipnpepi]

yes also the trouble is people start to argue about whats comedy and whats not lol

[lljwagg]

Um...no this idea has been posted before and got rejected because for people like you who mass post with 2 post's it makes it harder on them to post action and comedy videos because they would have to be switching sections as they post.And it also makes it easyer on people to find what they need if there not sure what cat to look in.

I don't understand what you mean by " 'people like you' who 'mass post' with 2 posts."
I simply (as an observer) made a relevant observation and suggestion.
Perhaps you could explain at what stage is it acceptable to make a suggestion?
Your reply seems a tad rude tbh, especially as I was only asking a simple question.
:|

[Cuddles]

lljwagg if you have a comedy album you want to upload just add to it by saying it is not music it is comedy that will solve the problem. There are just to many sections and to make one more just not a good idea in my thinking. But to do it like I said this is comedy not music, maybe add a few people that are on the album this way people know.

[Puddz]

yes also the trouble is people start to argue about whats comedy and whats not lol

if it makes more then 50% of the people thats listened to it, its funny. (they have more numbers and would win in an argument =D)

[drbits]

I don't think it is about funny or not. I think the original question was to separate spoken word (A-books), spoken performance (comedy or poetry), and audio that depends on music.

The problem is that there are many grey areas. Is the soundtrack of Oliver (a musical play/movie) a comedy (most of the songs are, the rest is not)? How about Fiddler on the Roof? That is a tragedy (by traditional standards) with some very funny parts. PDQ Bach is a little more obscure, but it is comedy about music.

[Gismo]

check the post date before re-hashing old topics

http://i40.tinypic.com/akykjk.gif